I’ve worked in several PICUs over the years. Some were as large as 36 beds (which counts as pretty large in the PICU world), and some were as small as 4 beds. Inevitably, larger PICUs can offer services that smaller ones cannot. This is particularly the case with more specialized services, like some kinds of surgery and access to super-specialists. When I’ve been in a smaller unit, there have been times when I’ve needed to transfer children to a larger one so they could get these more esoteric services. When I’ve been in a larger unit, I’ve received transfers of kids like that. Would these children who needed transfer have been better off going to the larger PICU in the first place?
The dilemma for smaller PICUs is that they can never become as experienced in caring for children with rare conditions, and it is hard for someone working in one of the smaller units to keep their skill levels up. Research has shown, not surprisingly, that physicians who do the same thing a lot are better at doing it than physicians who don’t do it so often. On the other hand, transferring a child from a local, smaller PICU to a bigger one is often hard on families, since often the larger unit is in another city — sometimes in another state. And many PICU problems can be handled just fine in a smaller place, nearer to home.
The process of transferring a critically ill child — by ambulance, helicopter, or airplane — carries risks, too. These risks are not just those inherent in traffic or flight. I can tell you from personal experience that no matter how much supplies and equipment you bring on the transport, you still can’t recreate a PICU. And the simple working environment of a transport vehicle, especially a helicopter, is cramped and noisy — far from optimal. So sometimes a critically ill child is safer staying where they are, at least until they can be made more stable.
What to do? As pediatric intensivists, we are sort of feeling our way as we figure this out. Most smaller PICUs have formal or informal relationships with larger units to which they can send children they cannot handle. But these relationships are a patchwork across the nation — we simply don’t know the ideal size for a PICU. When PICUs began several decades ago they were rare, found only in large children’s hospitals. In those days people’s expectations were different about what smaller community hospitals needed to provide. In today’s world, we believe all children should have access to the same life-saving PICU care. So smaller hospitals began to open PICUs to provide that care as best they could. Someday PICU care may be truly regionalized, with formal relationships between big and small units in the region, complete with standardized criteria for appropriate care at one unit or the other. We don’t have anything like that yet.
What parents should realize is that there are differences between what a smaller and a larger PICU can do. If your child has a particularly unusual or difficult problem, it is never inappropriate to ask your child’s doctor if transfer to a larger unit makes sense.
08/09/2009 • I've worked in several PICUs over the years. Some were as large as 36 beds (which counts as pretty large in the PICU world), and some were as small as 4 beds. Inevitably, larger PICUs ...more
03/21/2011 • I've worked in several PICUs over the years. Some were as large as 36 beds (which counts as pretty large in the PICU world), and some were as small as 4 beds. Inevitably, larger PICUs ...more
08/15/2011 • A hundred years ago virtually all decisions about how to care for sick children came from the child's family. It was the norm. By mid-century, though, things had changed significantly. Medical professionals—doctors and nurses—were making ...more
09/13/2010 • The short answer is that there aren't any. I've written before about how hard it is for parents to know if the PICU there child is in is a good one or not. All they ...more
09/20/2008 • There are about 400 PICUs in the United States. It is hard to know the exact number because, although several organizations have proposed standards, these facilities are self-identified. So a hospital is free to designate ...more
Leave a Reply
05/11/2013 • This is a topic that comes up from time to time for often spirited discussion. The most recent example comes in a a couple of articles in the New England Journal of Medicine. One was a ...more
01/21/2013 • I've written about this before, but it's well worth doing it again. It's once more cold season, bringing up the question parents commonly face: Should they buy one of those rows and rows of cough, ...more
11/26/2012 • A recent little essay at KevinMD entitled "Do patients bond best with doctors who misinform them with optimism" got me thinking about balancing honesty and optimism in practicing any medical specialty in which patients not ...more
10/15/2012 • There are some important new recommendations both about strep throats in general and about tonsillectomy -- taking out the tonsils -- as a treatment for recurrent strep throats. Some of us can recall a time when ...more